9 Essential ERP Selection Criteria for Retail and Consumer Goods Companies in 2025

For both Retail and Consumer Goods companies, selecting the right ERP system is critical. The ERP selection criteria for retail and consumer goods can significantly enhance efficiency, improve visibility, and streamline operations. In industries like these, an ERP provides the stability and structure needed to thrive in dynamic, fast-paced markets. However, selecting the right ERP for your business requires careful consideration of key features. Below are 9 essential criteria to guide your selection process. 

ERP selection criteria for retail and consumer goods

Industry specifical features  

The ERP selection criteria for retail and consumer goods starts with ensuring that the chosen ERP system includes robust features like Inventory and Supply Chain Management, Point of Sale Integration, and Financial Management, among others. See an outline of these below:

Feature Key Benefits
Inventory & Supply Chain Real-time tracking, demand forecasting, and supplier management
Point of Sale (POS) Integration Sync in-store and online sales, real-time data analysis, and CRM integration
Financial Management Multi-currency accounting, automated reporting, and profitability analysis
Omnichannel Capabilities Unified customer view, consistent pricing, and optimised order fulfillment
Product Lifecycle Management New product launches, quality control, and compliance tracking
Analytics & Intelligence Custom dashboards, trend forecasting, and data-driven insights

Compliance and security in ERP systems

When selecting an ERP system, regardless of the industry, it is crucial to prioritise the compliance and security features it provides. This ensures adherence to industry regulations, safeguards confidential data, defends against cyber threats, and strengthens both operational reliability and customer confidence. A robust ERP solution should offer multi-layered protection. 

Additionally, continuous monitoring for suspicious activities, regular security audits, and incident response protocols are vital for identifying and mitigating potential threats. By focusing on these aspects, organisations can enhance operational reliability, safeguard against cyber threats, and build customer trust in an increasingly digital landscape.

Operational agility and scalability for ERP

When selecting an ERP system, it’s important to consider operational agility and scalability to future-proof your business. A flexible and scalable ERP solution will be able to adapt to your evolving needs, accommodating growth, market changes, and new business processes. Look for features such as modular architecture, which allows for easy addition or modification of functionalities, and cloud-based solutions that offer on-demand resource scaling. The system should also support easy integration with emerging technologies like AI, IoT, or blockchain.

If you’re looking for and ERP system to come along a growth journey with you then you’ll need to consider the ERP’s ability to handle increased data volumes, user counts, and transaction loads without compromising performance. By choosing an agile and scalable ERP, businesses can ensure long-term value, reduce total cost of ownership, and maintain a competitive edge in rapidly changing markets.

You can read more about customisation vs configuration of ERP systems here.

User-friendly ERP interface

A new ERP system is a notable change and transition for any organisation, so it is worth ensuring the chosen system has a user-friendly interface as well as material to help onboard and support users. A well-designed interface enhances user adoption and minimises resistance to change by providing intuitive navigation and clear workflows. You could look for systems that offer customisable dashboards, allowing users to tailor their experience based on individual roles and preferences.

Additionally, comprehensive onboarding materials—such as tutorials, documentation, and interactive training sessions—are vital for empowering users to leverage the system effectively from day one. Ongoing support resources, including help centers or dedicated customer service teams, can further facilitate a smooth transition. By investing in an ERP with a user-friendly interface and robust support materials, organisations can enhance productivity, reduce training time, and ultimately drive greater return on investment from their ERP implementation.

Comprehensive reporting capabilities

Robust reporting functionality is important to consider for any effective ERP system, playing a crucial role in informed decision-making and operational excellence. When evaluating ERP vendors, you may want to prioritise solutions offering comprehensive reporting capabilities that go beyond basic data aggregation. Systems featuring customisable dashboards, real-time analytics, and predictive modeling tools is a good place to start. Advanced ERP reporting should enable organisations to generate actionable insights across various business dimensions, from financial performance and inventory management to customer behavior and supply chain efficiency. By leveraging these reporting capabilities, organisations can make data-driven decisions swiftly, identify trends and anomalies proactively, optimise resource allocation, and gain a competitive edge through enhanced strategic planning and execution.

System Interoperability and API-First Approach  

When selecting an ERP system, prioritising an API-first approach is crucial for seamless integration with your organisation’s existing tools. Here are the key benefits:

  • Seamless Integration: An API-first ERP facilitates real-time data exchange across various platforms, ensuring smooth communication between systems.

  • Custom Integrations: This approach allows for tailored integrations that meet specific business needs, enhancing operational flexibility.

  • Well-Documented APIs: Look for ERP solutions that offer RESTful APIs with comprehensive documentation, making it easier for developers to implement integrations.

  • Operational Efficiency: Strong interoperability helps break down data silos, streamline workflows, and improve data accuracy across departments.

ERP total cost ownership

When evaluating ERP systems, consider these factors to understand the true cost:

ERP Total Cost of Ownership: Key Considerations
Initial Costs • Software licensing fees
• Implementation expenses
• Hardware upgrades (if needed)
Ongoing Expenses • Annual maintenance fees
• Regular software updates
• Customisation costs
Indirect Costs • Staff training
• Productivity changes during transition
• Data migration resources
Vendor Support • Level of included support
• Cost of additional support services
• Vendor’s track record for updates and patches
Long-term Considerations • Scalability for business growth
• Integration with future technologies
• Potential cost savings from improved efficiency

By considering all of the elements that apply to you in the cost consideration table above you will be able to paint a more accurate picture of the financial investment required for your needs with an ERP implementation project.

ERP Vendor experience in Retail and Consumer Goods

When shortlisting ERP vendors for the retail and consumer goods sectors, organisations face a complex decision. While vendors with proven implementation success and industry-specific functionality are crucial, the evaluation process requires an unbiased, comprehensive approach. Key considerations include the vendor’s expertise in advanced demand forecasting, multi-channel sales management, and supply chain optimisation, as well as their integration of emerging technologies like AI and IoT.

However, interpreting vendor claims and capabilities in the context of your specific business needs requires deep industry knowledge. Be sure to consider aligning ERP choices with broader business strategy, ensuring the selected solution not only meets current requirements but also supports future growth. This strategic approach, combining vendor capabilities with expert analysis, is essential for driving long-term operational excellence and competitive advantage in the dynamic retail and consumer goods landscape. For more guided information about how to choose the right technology click here.

Future innovation and roadmap

When evaluating ERP systems, it’s essential to look beyond current functionalities and assess the vendor’s future roadmap and innovation potential. Leading vendors are integrating AI and predictive analytics to enhance decision-making, while IoT convergence allows for real-time monitoring of assets, optimising operations and reducing downtime. Additionally, cloud-based solutions provide flexibility and scalability, ensuring clients receive regular updates with the latest features. By focusing on industry-specific solutions, vendors are tailoring their offerings to meet unique operational needs. Thoroughly investigating a vendor’s innovation roadmap ensures that your chosen ERP system will not only meet your current requirements but also evolve to keep you ahead of the competition.

Choose the right ERP for your business

In the dynamic world of retail and consumer goods, selecting the right ERP system is not just a decision – it’s a strategic move that can accelerate your organisation in many ways. By understanding and applying our 9 selection criteria, you can confidently navigate the complexities of the ERP landscape and choose a vendor that aligns with your unique needs.

Don’t leave it to chance though! If you have any questions or need further advice on choosing the right technology for your business then we’re always happy to start a conversation. All you have to do is get in touch.

Why Choose Us

At Nine Feet Tall, we quickly integrate into your team, building momentum from day one while sharing our expertise to upskill your staff. Our open and honest communication style ensures transparency without unnecessary bureaucracy. With a deep understanding of industry challenges and trends, we bring fresh insights and best practices, empowering your organisation to realise the full benefits of change.

From the blog

  • ERP for Supply Chain Efficiency in Retail: Unlocking Operational Benefits

  • ERP Cybersecurity Considerations for Successful Deployment

  • Choosing the Right Technology as an IT Leader: From Legacy to Leading-Edge